Google Inc. on Monday appeared to be set for a renewed clash with Turkey’s government, when it reposted videos that a court had ruled insulting to the republic’s founder Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, effectively rejecting an attempt to end a ban on YouTube in Turkey, The Wall Street Journal reports.
The four videos, which have kept YouTube banned here since May 2008, were taken off the Web late last week by a Turkish group of self-described “volunteers,” working closely with the government. The group used Google’s automatic copyright protection system to have the clips removed.
Turks were able to access YouTube directly for the first time in more than two years last weekend, after a court on Saturday lifted the ban, noting that the offending clips were now gone. Google, however, said Monday it was restoring the videos, while critics described the volunteers’ copyright plan as an enabler for censorship.
“When we looked into this, we found the videos were not, in fact, copyright infringing, so we have put them back up, though they continue to be restricted within Turkey. We hope very much that our users in Turkey can continue to enjoy YouTube,” the company said in a statement. A spokesperson declined comment further.
The head of Turkey’s Telecommunications Transmission Directorate, which is responsible for enforcing Internet bans, said he would meet with YouTube officials “in the coming days.”
Serhat Ozeren, who heads the semi-independent Internet Board of Turkey, said in an interview that the YouTube statement was being treated as unofficial, but that if it proved correct “it would make it more difficult for our board to defend YouTube” and the ban could easily resume.